期刊问答网 论文发表 期刊发表 期刊问答
  • 回答数

    2

  • 浏览数

    131

虽然如同
首页 > 期刊问答网 > 期刊问答 > commentary算论文吗有用吗

2个回答 默认排序1
  • 默认排序
  • 按时间排序

幽谷主人

已采纳
算。Letter(也作correspondence)是信件或通信的意思,是读者写给杂志编辑的信。它是很多期刊为读者所开设的反馈意见的专栏。一般地,Letter有三种形式:第一种是对本期刊最新发布的论著进行评论;第二种是对其他期刊最新发布的论著进行评论;第三种是research letter,投稿类似于论著,但篇幅短,不属于标准的article类别。在晋升职称的时候,要求高的单位并不认可letter。尽管如此,letter和commentary(述评,系统性地就某一或多篇论著共同的话题所作的论述)一样发挥着对论著研究的补充作用,对论著中的方法及结果进行评价或批判,并提出进一步研究或改进的建议。如果是研究型letter,那么它一定是很能吸引眼球、对临床或者基础研究起到推导作用的重要发现。

commentary算论文吗有用吗

191 评论(14)

absq

这玩意根本就没有什么格式写法你就审好题 抓住要点 然后根据自己的知识储备谈谈你的理解就行了这种题主要是考你的独立思考能力的 当然阅读能力和知识储备都很重要summarize : 简要说明文章讨论的论点,最后提出一个问题(你自己想到的假设或者问题)引起读者兴趣commentary: 针对这个问题进行你的观点表达。下面是我找的关于怎样写commentary的方法,希望你不要晕了。There is no recipe for doing The elements that make up a successful commentary tend to vary and will depend on the nature of the text and on particular approaches to Nor is there a single 'right answer' to any passage for A good commentary may well consist of a number of pertinent questions raised by the However, certain tendencies should be avoided: A commentary should not be a précis of the Summary and description are not It is generally preferable not to proceed line-by-line through a passage from beginning to end; instead, one should identify important themes or elements and then discuss each of those in turn, illustrating with examples from the A commentary should not dwell on the context of the passage and should in general avoid venturing into other parts of the work from which the extract is It should likewise avoid excursions into the wider oeuvre of the It is quite possible to write a successful commentary on a passage drawn from a text with which one is unfamiliar, as commentary is meant to be an exercise in analysis OF THE GIVEN PASSAGE Any comments that do concern the wider context should remain They must emerge directly from an analysis of the passage or illuminate it in some There should be a clear distinction between a commentary (focussed on a particular passage) and an essay that discusses an entire work or authorial It is not necessary to write out quotations from the This can waste valuable Passages for commentary in examinations always have the lines numbered and it is easier and more economical to refer to extracts by citing The following points should be considered: A commentary benefits by paying close attention to the use of Depending on the text, this might include (but need not be limited to) some or all of the following: use of rhyme, metre, and alliteration; lexical choices which mean that particular words are given prominence or carry special significance; syntax, especially when this is manipulated to highlight meaning, to create ambiguity, or to interact with poetic verse form; grammatical features such as sequences of verb tenses which might be used to create a particular temporal It should be remembered, though, that there is no point in simply describing such features if one does not also explain how or why they are important or It adds little or nothing to an understanding of a passage if the commentary merely identifies verb tenses, states that alliteration takes place, or reports the number of syllables per line of verse, and lets it go at It should be remembered that language is no less important in passages of prose or in discursive It is important to pay attention to the means of representation and to address not only the question of WHAT is said but that of HOW it is Questions concerning voice, perspective, and point of view may be considered, as might, for example, the relations between the voice of the text and the reader/ Equally, a good commentary may well consider the assumptions that are implicitly or explicitly made by the text or attributed to the reader and the ways in which configurations of imagery and thematic developments are set up and There is no need to ascribe to the text a definitive meaning or It is fine to problematize the Indeed, in certain circumstances, this may even be Good commentaries will often point out ambiguities or inconsistencies and suggest possible alternative Commentaries need not necessarily be exhaustive but can afford to emphasise particular themes and facets of the Ideally, the different points raised by a passage for commentary should be synthesised into an argument and one should try to avoid inventories of discrete points and observations
247 评论(8)

相关问答